| For Democracy | Municipal

| Home | Farsi | Adcocacy |

| Federal | 2025 |
| Provincial |
| Municipal | 2026 | 2022 | 2023 | 2018 |

In Toronto city council elections over the last 20 years (covering six municipal elections: 2003, 2006, 2010, 2014, 2018, and 2022), a non-incumbent challenger defeating a sitting councillor in a standard ward race is an exceedingly rare event—occurring only 6 times out of roughly 220 ward races (~2.7%).

While news headlines occasionally report higher numbers of incumbent losses (such as in 2018), those statistics are inflated by structural disruptions—such as the province cutting Toronto's council seats in half, forcing sitting councillors to run against each other.

Election-by-Election Breakdown
Election Year	Total Council Seats	Incumbents Defeated by Non-Incumbent Challengers	Details & Context
2022	25	1	Amber Morley defeated long-time incumbent Mark Grimes (Ward 3). All other running incumbents won.
2018	25	2*	Jennifer McKelvie defeated incumbent Neethan Shan (Ward 25). Mike Colle defeated Christin Carmichael Greb (Ward 8). (Note: 11 other incumbents lost because the province cut council from 44 to 25 seats, forcing incumbent-vs-incumbent matchups).
2014	44	2	Jon Burnside defeated John Parker (Ward 26). Justin Di Ciano defeated Peter Leon (Ward 3 - appointed incumbent).
2010	44	1	Jaye Robinson defeated long-time incumbent John Parker (Ward 25 under the 44-ward system).
2006	44	0	0 incumbents lost. Every single sitting councillor who ran for re-election retained their seat.
2003	44	0	0 incumbents lost. No running incumbent was defeated by a challenger.

The Reality of the Numbers

The Pure Challenger Success Rate (~2.7%): Outside of the artificial 2018 ward-cutting scenario where councillors were forced to eliminate one another, a total of only 6 sitting councillors have been unseated by non-incumbent challengers across 20 years.
The 97%+ Re-election Rate: In any given election, a running Toronto city councillor has an approximately 97% chance of re-election.
The 2018 Anomaly: In 2018, 13 incumbents lost their seats. However, 11 of those 13 were sitting councillors defeated by other sitting councillors because Ward boundaries were merged overnight (e.g., Josh Matlow beating Joe Mihevc; Frances Nunziata beating Frank Di Giorgio). Only 2 true non-incumbents won against an incumbent that year.